News

New research explores the impacts of continuous cover forestry in Sweden

Published: 24 January 2024
Forest with trees of different ages. Photo.

Gap cutting and selective logging are two forestry methods that involve leaving more trees standing during harvesting compared to traditional clear-cutting practices. However, how do these methods impact species and ecosystem services? Researchers at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) aim to investigate this in a new project, revisiting old experimental forests using clearcut-free methods and mapping suitable areas in Sweden for such forestry practices.

Currently, nearly all of Sweden's forests are managed using even-aged forestry, where the forest is clear-cut after 60 to 120 years and then replanted with new trees.

"The final harvest and the subsequent clear-cut phase disadvantage several forest-dwelling species. There is a growing societal interest in alternative management methods, such as selective logging and continuous cover forestry. The hope is that such methods will benefit biodiversity and forest ecosystem services," says Jörgen Sjögren, a researcher at SLU and the leader of the study.

Simultaneous studies of species and ecosystem services

Selective logging involves harvesting the largest trees at intervals of approximately every fifth to fifteenth year, while gap cutting creates smaller openings in the forest (see fact box below). Currently, there is limited knowledge on how selective logging and gap cutting affect biodiversity and ecosystem services.

Separate studies have shown, for example, that several bird species benefit from leaving small and medium-sized trees during forestry operations, while lichens living lower on tree trunks are disadvantaged due to shading from the retained small trees. Regarding timber production, it is challenging to draw clear conclusions about how it is affected by non-clearcut methods. Summarizing previous research on forest ecosystem services, some studies indicate a decrease in timber production with clearcut-free methods, while others show a slightly increased timber production. Blueberry shrubs benefit from leaving more trees during forestry operations.

"This underscores the need to study multiple species groups and ecosystem services simultaneously when examining the effects of a new forestry system, which has not been done on a larger scale concerning selective logging and gap cutting. We aim to change that with our research," says Jörgen Sjögren.

Study areas in Sweden and Finland

The research will be conducted in several Swedish and Finnish forests where some studies on species and ecosystem services related to selective logging and gap cutting have already been carried out. These data will be supplemented with new investigations. A total of seven different species groups (for example mosses, lichens, beetles, and vascular plants) will be included in the study.

"Transitioning from one management method to another requires suitable and accessible forests for the new methods. Mapping where in the country such forests are located is also part of the project," says Jörgen Sjögren.

For example, selective logging requires a forest with trees of all sizes but with significantly more small trees than large ones, known as a full-layered forest.

"With this project, we aim to contribute to increased knowledge about how biodiversity is affected by these management methods," concludes Jörgen Sjögren.

Facts:

Facts about the project and collaborators

The project "Continuous Cover Forestry and its Effects on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services in the Short and Long Term" is funded by the Swedish Research Council Formas and runs from 2022 to 2026. The research is conducted at SLU in collaboration with the Finnish Forest Research Institute LUKE in Helsinki and Uppsala University.

Facts about clearcut-free forestry

Clearcut-free forestry, as defined by the Swedish Forest Agency, involves managing forests without creating large clear-cut areas. It is a broad term that encompasses various ways of forest management.

Selective logging: Best suited for spruce forests in Sweden. It requires a forest with trees of all sizes in all parts of the forest, with significantly more small trees than large ones, known as a fully stocked forest. In continuous cover forestry, the largest trees are harvested at intervals of approximately every fifth to fifteenth year.

Gap-cutting: Involves creating smaller openings in the forest. The size of these openings should not exceed 0.25 hectares. As these openings fill in with new trees, existing openings can be expanded or new ones created. Chessboard logging is a variant of selective logging where harvesting occurs in a grid pattern, like a chessboard.

Shelterwood: Well-suited for light-demanding tree species such as pine. In the shelterwood system, a certain number of evenly distributed trees are retained during final harvesting. After the new forest is established, a proportion of the retained trees are harvested.